Please note that you are using an outdated version of Internet Explorer which is not compatible with some elements of the site. We strongly urge you to update to a newer version for optimal browsing experience.

What to do when your neighbour’s home is devaluing your property

27 Nov 2018

Much like how that one scuffed dining room chair will lower the value of the whole set, one unkept property will drag down the prices of all the surrounding homes.

If you are not the type who is comfortable with engaging in direct confrontation, you could find an opportunity to chat to them and strategically mention that you know a great garden service or cleaning professional with whom you’d be happy to put them in touch.

Regional Director and CEO of RE/MAX of Southern Africa, Adrian Goslett, warns that as thorough as you might have been in your suburb research before buying your current home, living next to a negligent neighbour can happen to anyone at any point in time.

“Nobody can predict the future. All it takes is for your current neighbours to fall into some financial crisis that causes their home to go to wrack and ruin, or to relocate and have a real-world version of ‘The Addam’s Family’ move in next door. The unfortunate reality is that homeowners do not have many options available to them if ever they find themselves in this situation,” Goslett explains.

“It is very difficult when a neighbour fails to maintain their property to a certain standard. You can request that a neighbour takes certain steps to neaten up their property, but there is very little one can do to force their hand - especially when the property is situated on a freehold erf,” says Kim Peacock, Broker/Owner of RE/MAX Dolphin Realtors.

“Having said that, if a property is situated in a lifestyle estate, it is very easy to take action as there are rules and guidelines in place to which each and every homeowner must adhere. You simply would need to report the property in question to the homeowner’s association (HOA) who would ensure proper maintenance takes place.”

For those who do not own property in a lifestyle estate governed by an HOA or body corporate, RE/MAX of Southern Africa has compiled a few diplomatic approaches to dealing with negligent neighbours:

1. Be neighbourly

Don’t be too hasty in your anger against your neighbour. You might not know what could have happened to cause their house to stand derelict. Instead of sitting in your home nursing feeling indignant, approach them and show some neighbourly concern for the sudden change in the appearance of their home and find out if there is any way you could help.

2. Take the straightforward approach

Diplomacy is key in this approach. Nobody wants animosity to exist between themselves and their neighbours. If you approach them calmly, kindly explaining the situation and requesting that they tidy up the exterior of their home (at the least while your home is on the market), you might find that they were unaware of the effect they were having and would be happy to oblige. Of course, it is also likely that they simply don’t care how the appearance of their home affects you. However, you won’t know unless you ask.

3. Drop not-so-subtle hints

If you are not the type who is comfortable in engaging in direct confrontation, you could find an opportunity to chat to them and strategically mention that you know a great garden service or cleaning professional with whom you’d be happy to put them in touch. If the appearance of their home really bugs you, and your home is currently on the market, you could offer to pay to get the exterior fixed up for them.

It’s possible that your neighbour won’t turn down the free offer and, while it might cost you a couple of hundred (or thousand depending on the extent of the damage) to hire some professionals for them, it could save you tens of thousands in terms of the resale value of your own property.

For those who are currently experiencing this exact crisis and are not sure how to deal with it, Goslett suggests they partner with a trusted local estate agent who can help them sell at as close to full value as possible.

“As experts in the industry, estate agents are not just the superfluous middleman between buyers and sellers, but are knowledgeable consultants with years of experience who are able to help buyers and sellers through the various complicated realities involved in property transactions,” says Goslett.

Print Print
Top Articles
From beaches to stunning vistas, tranquillity and more, these homes in Fish Hoek, Simons Town, Kalk Bay, Gordons Bay and Muizenberg offer idyllic coastal living. Take a peek…

From Camps Bay to Gordon's Bay, Hermanus, Pringle Bay, St Francis and Paternoster on the West Coast plus more, here's what you'll pay for holiday flats and houses...

Across 30 malls analysed, all except two showed Black Friday week was more popular than 2018, with lower LSM shoppers spending 22.7% more on the day. Get the lowdown...


Your browser is out of date!

It looks like you are using an outdated version of Internet Explorer.

If you are using Internet Explorer 8 or higher, please verify that your Internet Explorer compatibility view settings are not enabled.

For the best browsing experience, update to the latest Version of Internet Explorer or try out Google Chrome or Mozilla Firefox.

Please contact our Property24 Support Team for further assistance. Tel. +27 (0)861 111 724